Introduction

Ireland’s housing crisis isn't simply a technical failure of supply, or the consequence of “market forces” run amok. This is the latest episode in the long-running land question that has shaped Irish political life for more than a century and a half: who controls the material basis of life and whose interest is served? For the socialist-republican perspective, secure housing is a condition of non-domination — the practical ability for ordinary people to live free from the arbitrary interference of landlords, creditors or speculative capital. Ireland spent a century dismantling landlordism, but the state has facilitated a new class of landlords to emerge. The current crisis, with homelessness at record levels, prices that have already sailed past previous peaks and a continuing deficit of homes against even modest estimates of need, represents a reversal of hard-won gains.

What makes the change so striking is that it wasn’t inevitable. For half a century, the State made effective use of public land, compulsory purchase and local-authority building to bring housing out of the landlord system. Since 2008, it has used NAMA, REITs and tax policy to put it back in. The obvious question which arises is, why did the State unlearn what it once knew how to do? Secure housing is a condition of non-domination the practical ability to live free from the arbitrary interference of landlords, creditors or speculative capital. The distinction that matters is an old one: a right is something you can claim; a mercy is something you are granted. A tenant with a notice period has a mercy, not a right.

The Land Question, Then and Now

In the 19th century, James Fintan Lalor challenged the sanctity of property rights when they came at the expense of people's survival. He rejected any right of property “which denies to the peasant the right of a home and concedes, in exchange, the right of a workhouse.” Subsequently cited by former President Michael D. Higgins, Lalor's words retain a striking contemporary relevance: in an Ireland where housing is increasingly treated as a financial asset, they pose a fundamental question about whose rights the property system is designed to protect, and whose are sacrificed in the process.

It’s a harsh reality. By Autumn 2026, over 17,800 individuals, including around 5,800 children, were living in state-funded emergency housing — a 9% increase in only one year. The scores of individuals who sleep on the streets, couch surf, or stay at domestic violence shelters are not included in these statistics. While the Residential Property Price Index kept rising, the median price of a home bought in the 12 months leading up to August 2026 was €400,000. Although structural demand projections from the Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI) vary between 35,000 and 53,000 dwellings annually depending on migration and household-size assumptions, completions hit a post-crisis high of slightly over 36,000 in 2025 and are predicted to approach 39,000-40,000 in 2026. For that large section of the population specifically recognised by Tone and Pearse, the "men and women of no property," the gap isn't decreasing quickly enough to restore security.

This isn't a novel predicament. The nineteenth-century Land War and the subsequent Wyndham-era purchase schemesbegan the gradual transfer of ownership from landlord to tenant. After administrative independence, the 1923 Land Act and the reconstituted Land Commission accelerated that transfer, using compulsory powers to break up large estates and redistribute land. Historians such as Terence Dooley have shown how the Commission functioned as an instrument of social engineering well into the mid-twentieth century, embedding the idea that access to land was inseparable from national independence and individual security. Parallel to this rural transformation ran a substantial programme of local-authority housing that, for several decades, treated the home as a use-value, rather than a pure commodity.

The post-2008 period was a major turning point. The National Asset Management Agency (NAMA) was tasked with managing distressed property assets, and the introduction of Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITS) in 2013 provided a tax-efficient vehicle for institutional capital. A 2013 report remarked that “a key part of NAMA's strategy in Ireland has been to create property portfolios which are attractive to large institutional buyers in the market, including REITs, which tend to favour sizeable transactions.” Successive governments actively courted global funds as buyers of both existing stock and new build-to-rent schemes. The result has been a measurable financialisation of the residential sector. Research has found that institutional investors have pushed rents up more steeply than other landlords after buying property, while large landlords with more than 100 tenancies now hold a significant and growing share of the Dublin rental market. IRES REIT, Ireland’s largest private residential landlord, is also a product of NAMA-era asset transfers and recently became the subject of a major takeover by a major US investment firm. Over the past few years, rents in Ireland have climbed sharply, with market rents now 42% higher than pre-Covid levels and 78% more than their Celtic Tiger peak.

Old Struggles in New Clothes

James Connolly saw continuation with remarkable acuity. Writing for the ‘Workers’ Republic’ in 1899, he insisted that “the land, alike in city and country, is the property of the entire people,” and that rent itself was simply “the modern substitute for the tribute exacted from the dispossessed.” Similar logic applies with full force today. What was once extracted by a historic alien landlord class is now extracted, in updated form, by institutional investors, REITs and the financial instruments that treat homes as assets, rather than as the material basis of independent life.

The consequence is a new form of domination. Renters live under the constant possibility that a landlord can raise the rent or end the tenancy at will, would-be owners confront deposit barriers and prices that have long outstripped wages. In September 2026, the ESRI documented that property prices are presently overvalued by 17%, referring to it as “a significant degree of overvaluation.”

This isn’t a mere economic inconvenience. In the neo-republican language of freedom as non-domination, which the philosopher Philip Pettit has already engaged, citizens are unfree when they remain subject to the unchecked power of those who control the places in which they live. Referring to the ideas of Theobald Wolfe Tone, Pettit outlines how one isn’t free simply because those with power choose not to interfere. Rather, if they could interfere at any moment, an individual is simply at their mercy. The mid-century public-housing tradition and the earlier land-reform project both rested on the premise that a form of democratic self-rule required a protected sphere in which people could act, without needing permission from a landlord or creditor. That premise has been inverted.

A New Social Order

What would a left-republican answer look like? First, a decisive move to public and AHB/co-operative construction at scale (as suggested by the National Economic and Social Council), treating land and housing as collective rather than purely private goods. Second, the active use ofland value sharing, so that the uplift created by public infrastructure and planning decisions accrues to the community, not a corporate landowner. Third, it would involve actively promoting and expanding Community Land Trusts and mutual home-ownership models that take land out of the speculative cycle in perpetuity. The Affordable Housing Act 2021 already recognises community land trusts and housing co-operatives as legitimate partners for local authorities. Now, the task is to give that recognition operational effect in reality through dedicated finance, preferential access to public land and a statutory definition that upholds the asset lock.

None of these instruments are utopian. Ireland has already demonstrated, in the Land Commission era and in the mid-century local-authority drive, that the state can act as a purposeful agent of redistribution when political will exists. The same capacity can be redirected toward urban and suburban land. Democratic planning that would be transparent, participatory, and oriented toward use-value - can serve as the necessary counterpart. The State could lead the way by reviving the spirit of the National Building Agency during the 1960s, a semi-state body set up to address the limitations of both local authorities and the private market, which successfully delivered housing at speed and scale. A contemporary equivalent, armed with land-acquisition powers and a clear public-interest mandate, would enable the State to take direct responsibility for building homes which the market has repeatedly failed to provide. Purely regulatory approaches that leave ownership structures intact, however well-intentioned, will not break the cycle of speculation and exclusion. As Lalor asserted in 1847, “a new adjustment is now to be formed, is to form and develop itself; a new social order to be arranged; a new people to be organised.” This is the ambition required in order to solve the housing crisis in Ireland.

The Stakes of Self-Rule

The crisis is therefore also an opportunity. Far-right currents have exploited the housing crisis and utilised nationalist symbols to further their aims. Uninspired, centrist politics continues to treat the problem as one of incremental supply-side management. A living republican tradition, rooted in the materialist insights of its historical leaders, has a different answer. That is, the recovery of collective control over the conditions of everyday life. Housing isn’t just another welfare issue. Rather, it’s the contemporary version of the old land question in Ireland, and the test of whether self-rule means anything beyond the formal symbols of a state.

A population that must ask a fund's permission to remain in their own home are not self-governing. They hold these properties as a mercy, not a right. In the end, the question returns to the one the revolutionary generation couldn’t escape - who controls the material basis of life, and therefore the capacity for self-rule? As Liam Mellows, writing in the ‘Workers’ Republic,’ warned in 1922, “whoever controls the wealth of a country and the processes by which wealth is attained, controls also its government.” Today, the financialisation of housing has handed that control to foreign capital and global funds, leaving Ireland, in Mellows’ words, once again “at the mercy of every breeze that ruffled the surface of the world’s money markets.”


Tadgh Ó Cuill-Maonlaí is a trainee barrister at the King's Inns. He is a volunteer board member of Coláiste na Mumhan, the oldest Gaeltacht training college. He has had poetry and local history features published 'as Gaeilge.' He is a volunteer board member of Carbery Housing Association, a housing charity operating in Cork city and county, and is an elected member of the Council of the Irish Council for Social Housing.

The link has been copied!